The aim of these articles is to keep our Clients and Associates updated about developments in the sector of Intellectual Property in general and our firm in particular. In this way, we wish to provide a broader view of the tools that the field of trade marks, domain names, patents, designs and related rights offers to entrepreneurs to enhance and protect their efforts in researching and developing new solutions and ideas.
INTERPATENT Speakers at the Webinar: Protecting IP in the Age of Dupes
On 12 October 2026, INTERPATENT took part in the webinar “Protecting Trade Marks and Other Intellectual Property Rights in the Age of Dupes”, organised by the Turin Provincial Committee for the Fight Against Counterfeiting as part of the “PI Smart – IP Protection Strategies in the Digital Marketplace” series.
Our colleagues Manuela Bruscolini, Italian and European Trade Mark Attorney, and Stefano Baldi, Italian and European Patent Attorney, participated as speakers, sharing their expertise on the legal and practical challenges that the growing dupe phenomenon poses for businesses and intellectual property professionals.
The webinar was particularly timely, taking place just days before the 11th edition of the Italian Anti-Counterfeiting Week that took place from 19 to 23 October 2026, also featured in this issue of our newsletter, further highlighting the importance of effective IP protection in today's increasingly digital marketplace.
Understanding the Challenges Posed by Dupes
The term dupe, short for duplicate, generally refers to a more affordable product that takes inspiration from the appearance, features or appeal of a well-known product without necessarily reproducing its brand name or logo. Unlike conventional counterfeits, dupes are often openly presented as alternatives to the original, and consumers may knowingly choose them for their lower price.
This creates a different challenge for IP owners. Rather than necessarily misleading consumers about a product's commercial origin, dupe marketing may encourage consumers to feel that they are obtaining similar quality or aesthetics without paying the premium associated with an established brand.
Yet the development of an original product involves much more than its name or logo. Businesses invest in research and development, product design, technical improvements, marketing and brand recognition. When competitors capitalise on the results of these investments, questions arise about the limits of legitimate competition and the legal tools available to protect the value created by the original producer.
As discussed during the webinar, the absence of a copied brand name does not automatically rule out an infringement. The assessment depends on the elements reproduced, the intellectual property rights available and the way the competing product is presented and marketed. Equally, similarity alone does not necessarily establish unlawful conduct.
Beyond Likelihood of Confusion: The Role of Reputed Trade Marks
A key focus of Manuela Bruscolini's presentation was trade mark protection, including the enhanced protection available to marks with a reputation. While the likelihood of confusion remains an important criterion in trade mark infringement cases, it is not the only relevant consideration.
Under the applicable legal conditions, the owner of a reputed trade mark may also be able to oppose uses that take unfair advantage of, or are detrimental to, the mark's distinctive character or reputation, even where consumers are not confused about the commercial origin of the products.
Two significant cases illustrate these issues.
In L'Oréal v Bellure (Court of Justice of the European Union, Case C-487/07, 2009), the Court examined the marketing of imitation perfumes including packaging and comparative lists referring to well-known fragrances. The judgment clarified the relevance of taking unfair advantage of a trade mark's reputation, demonstrating that such protection is not limited to cases involving consumer confusion. The judgment clarified that taking unfair advantage of the distinctive character or reputation of a trade mark does not require a likelihood of confusion or damage to the mark itself. It may arise where a third party seeks to benefit from the attraction, reputation and marketing investment associated with a reputed mark. The decision remains an important reference point in assessing so-called free-riding, although it does not mean that every imitation is unlawful.
More recently, in Thatchers Cider Company Ltd v Aldi Stores Ltd ([2025] EWCA Civ 5, Court of Appeal of England and Wales, 20 January 2025), the court considered the packaging of Aldi's lemon cider in relation to Thatchers' registered figurative trade mark, which protected the graphic presentation associated with its product. The court of Appeal found that Aldi had taken unfair advantage of the reputation of the Thatchers mark, even though consumers were not likely to be confused about the commercial origin of the two products. The court considered, among other factors, the link created in consumers' minds and the commercial benefit Aldi obtained from Thatchers' investment in developing and promoting its product.
The case illustrates how the overall presentation of a product may become legally significant when it evokes a well-known brand and benefits from its appeal. Although the UK decision must be considered within its own legal framework, it provides a useful example of the challenges raised by look-alike products and the importance of assessing the specific circumstances of each case.
The discussion also highlighted the potential relevance of unfair competition rules, where the applicable legal requirements are met, particularly when a competitor systematically imitates another business's commercial initiatives.
Registered Designs: Protecting Product Appearance and Packaging
Stefano Baldi's contribution focused on the role of registered designs, patents and utility models in protecting the product itself, beyond its brand identity.
Registered designs can be particularly relevant in addressing dupes, since they protect the appearance of a product or part of a product, including its lines, contours, colours, shape, surface texture and materials, where the relevant requirements are satisfied.
In the European Union, design protection is based on the overall impression produced on the informed user. The scope of protection is therefore not necessarily limited to identical copies: a design may also be infringed by another design that does not produce a different overall impression, subject to the applicable legal requirements.
The webinar explored several ways in which businesses can make more strategic use of design registrations:
- Protecting individual product features. Rather than seeking protection only for the product as a whole, businesses may consider registering distinctive parts or visual elements. This can be particularly useful when dupe products reproduce selected features of an original product while changing its overall appearance.
- Considering multiple design filings. In jurisdictions where multiple applications are available, businesses may be able to protect several designs through a single application, potentially reducing filing costs and allowing them to cover different product variants.
- Extending protection to packaging. Since imitation may concern not only the product but also its packaging, it can be worth considering separate design protection for distinctive packaging elements and relevant variants.
- Building a portfolio proactively. In some jurisdictions, including the EU and Italy, design registrations can be obtained without a full substantive examination of novelty and individual character at the registration stage. This can facilitate relatively rapid and cost-effective protection, although the validity of the registered rights may still be challenged.
These strategies can help businesses develop a broader design portfolio that addresses not only direct copies but also products that reproduce selected visual elements. The appropriate approach will depend on the product, the relevant markets and the specific design rights available.
Patents and Utility Models: Protecting Technical Innovation
While designs primarily address appearance, patents and utility models can protect technical features that distinguish a product from competing alternatives.
A patent for an invention may protect a technical solution provided that the applicable requirements, including novelty, inventive step and industrial applicability, are met. The scope of protection is determined by the patent claims, meaning that it can extend to competing products incorporating the protected technical features even where their branding or external appearance differs.
Utility models, where available, can offer protection for certain technical improvements relating to the form or configuration of products, such as features that improve their usefulness or ease of application. Their requirements and procedures vary across jurisdictions.
As discussed during the webinar, patents and utility models may be less central to dupe-related disputes in sectors such as fashion and cosmetics, where imitation often focuses on appearance and brand appeal. However, they can be particularly valuable when a product incorporates genuine technical innovation.
Protecting these features can help businesses defend the technical advantages of their products independently of similarities in branding, shape or packaging. It also reinforces the importance of identifying and protecting innovation early, rather than relying exclusively on trade mark or design rights once imitation appears.
A Broader IP Strategy, Supported by Effective Enforcement
The webinar also considered the potential role of copyright, where the relevant requirements are met, as part of a wider strategy for protecting original product features and creative works.
The central message was that no single intellectual property right can address every form of imitation. Trade marks, registered designs, patents, utility models and copyright protect different aspects of a product and may complement one another. Identifying the appropriate combination requires an assessment of the product's distinctive characteristics, the available rights and the jurisdictions in which protection is needed.
Registration is only part of the process. Effective protection also requires monitoring marketplaces, social media and e-commerce platforms, collecting and preserving evidence, assessing potential infringements and selecting appropriate enforcement measures. Depending on the circumstances, these may include cease-and-desist letters, platform takedown requests or further legal action.
Protecting Innovation and Brand Value in a Digital Marketplace
The growing dupe phenomenon demonstrates that IP protection is not exclusively a concern for major luxury brands. Businesses of all sizes can face imitation when their products gain visibility and commercial traction. A proactive strategy can help identify protectable assets, establish a suitable portfolio of rights and support timely action when potentially infringing products appear on the market.
Through their contribution to the PI Smart initiative, Manuela Bruscolini and Stefano Baldi highlighted the importance of an integrated approach combining legal protection, strategic registrations, market monitoring and enforcement.
For businesses and IP professionals operating across different jurisdictions, understanding how these tools interact is essential to developing strategies tailored to the relevant rights, markets and circumstances.
INTERPATENT remains committed to supporting businesses and fellow IP professionals in protecting intellectual property, safeguarding innovation and addressing the evolving challenges of counterfeiting and imitation in an increasingly digital marketplace.


